I would like to hear YOUR oppinion...
Having some problems unfortunately..
Death2Uall Thanks for the advice if I will have some spare time I will make a remake of this remake :)
IsmiteU had the same idea abut the railgun ...
So it will have a rail and I might work on the lighting... Although I am allways having problems with that part... I dont know why.. It is propably the faul of my brother .. He made my cfg file and it screws up a lot of things includeing the ambience and intensity of lighting... And when I made a cvar_restart the game looked awfull... I have no idea what to do but hopefully my latest map will not have these lighting problems... I ll work on it.
I'm a rail freak though so take that however you want. :)
First of all, I think the architecture to this remake is awesome. I love the idea of a weathered down and crumbling version of dead simple. The architecture really conveys a sense of age (which is pretty fitting considering how old DOOM is). However, there are a couple of small things that I think could have made this WAY better.
The lighting is my biggest complaint. The map has the great beaten down architecture but the lighting doesn't fit IMO. Way, way too bright. A darker sky (maybe even a custom night sky) with light coming from some fires burning on the ground here and there and maybe a few torches would have looked awesome. It would have really accented the architecture and the overall setting brilliantly. I also have (and enjoy quite a bit) your Pit and the Pendulum map. If I were to criticize any area of your map making, it would have to be lighting. On this map and the Pit and the Pendulum, the lighting just looks rushed a little to me (well, a lot on this one and a little on the other). Just something I've noticed. Not trying to rag on you at all. I enjoy most of your maps a great deal.
Second is the total lack of enviornmental sound in this map. Just a simple wind howling would have been perfect (along with the crackling of aforementioned fires).
I KNOW you did this quickly and just for fun. I'm just offering up my opinions and actually hoping you might go back and touch it up a little. I think the concept is excellent and this map has always been a blast for the occasional beatdown. I love really high quality classic map remakes personally. They bring back great memories. Not enough good ones out there. Most are sub-par conversions without much thought put into them.
If by any chance you decide to touch it up at all in these areas, please let me know about it at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Do not expect too much. They are just for fun and were made in about three days...
If you want to make your self heard try the beta section. Because my latest map is under beta testing I would like to hear your oppinions.
Especially Abonimations :)