Fair. I'll have to actually check out this guy's other maps.

Honestly, I hadnt looked at previous maps by the author. There is a lot of high quality stuff there. Given that I was unaware of previous work, and that the gameplay and but support is very limited, I feel my review was fair. Imo maps like these can often feel more copy paste but I did express my enjoyment of the geometry and setting, being a huge halo fan.
It isnt a bad map by any degree but it couldnt hurt to give it some more love in editor.
Edited 1.6 minutes after the original posting.
Edited 21.77 hours after the original posting.

I think the reviewer is a bit harsh saying this is a beginner level. The guy has made maps for years. Since 2007 I think? He's clearly just experimenting. I think this map is quite creative with it's odd structures and stuff. I like having refreshers, things that are not the same copy and paste "perfect map."