Q2 Days where awesome :). Nice map. 8.5/10

Brings me back to the days of Q2!

Very nice indeed... I've played the remake for q4 but missed the water part... could you make one loyal to the original en terms of map but with the textures from q4, like the one you made?

Very Awesome map there! ^^ I love this one the best. 10 :)

Remake or not, in terms of detail vs. framerate vs. gameplay, this is one of the best Quake 3 maps ever produced.

9/10

Great map. Best Edge remix I've played.

But if I was gunna make one I'd get rid of the water to the rail gun. water is SO god damn annoying ;)

8/10: good work

the only new thing i can say it's the lightning : too uniform in my opinion..

7/10

This was reviewed long ago at Deja-Review (which is the place for things like these). It was good then, and still is now. 9/10

Never claimed it was a conspiracy.. and it doesnt piss me off, lol. Try reading my post before responding like that next time, thanks.

This is not a conspiracy to piss you off. Each one mapped what he felt like.

another edge remake?

This one looks pretty good, and remains pretty accurate to the original.. but cmon.. how many edge remakes do we need? I count 6 so far.

6/10 good map, but wheres the origninality?

Its a good thing this map has -ISH at the end of its title, this gives the author room for some artistic licence and with that in mind its a pretty cool alternative.

As far as conversions go though, there can be only one....and this aint it.

really nice map though :-)

7/10

Being a Q2Dm1 remaker myself naturaly I had to check this one out :)

I love it, it's the best looking one so far. It may not be as acurate in terms of gameplay to mine but definately a better looking map, nice choice of textures and lots of curvs. My only grips would be the main rock wall is a little flat and being able to see out of the water can lead to sneaky unfair rail attacks >:)

A good technique for the rock wall is to create a sphere then warp it a bit so its like a chunk of rock then cover it in caulk. Now use it to build up the wall rotating it each time to show a different set of faces, once its built make them all detail brushes and apply the rock texture to the visible faces. This way the rocks don't intersect each other when BSP'd and are also ignored by VIS.

Finaly cover them inteligently with cliping so as to not give the bots a head ache :)

For a look at mine
lvlworld.com/comments.php

Cheers!

yes i agree 12inches fileplanet gave up life lol and good map :)

Best remake to date, feels the same, looks kinda the same, like a make over on changing rooms, shame its hosted on:

FILE-IS-SHIT-SINCE-GAMESPY-TOOK-OVER-PLANET.COM yet another good service ruined by gamespy. good work dood