I suppose its a little late bumping a 13 year old discussion, but I give this map a 3/5.
Needs some death from above type ledges.
6
But I'll try my best.
Well that was my second map, ok the first one was even worse, and I understand that you all so qualified mappers don't like it, but I really don't understand why you find it that bad. I mean I really had a lot of work with that map, and I thought my new sounds and the easter-egg would be a bit funny, and you can say that I'm subjective now by saying all this, because it was me who did it, but in the beta-section there they don't loved it, but liked it, some maybe just a bit, a few (in fact two) also sent me e-amils that they appreciated my map.
But, all in all I know than there will be someone who gonna rediculize after I've posted this, but at least I can be proud of to have you made having fun with posting your so positive messages.